top of page

All History

Total Entries: 1046

Select one of the above filters

Year Filter:
Backwards
Recently Added
Clear Year
Search

Jan 16, 1933

​

Open Entry:

​

Ten Lessons on Meat - For use in schools

1/16/33

"Whipple's work showed that an animal makes good its losses after a severe hemorrhage much more rapidly if given an abundance of meat, and more recent observations have demonstrated the great value of liver in this respect. The application of these findings to the ordinary anemias of adult life and growing children should be apparent."

Dietary Importance of Meat in Disease 


One of the most important contributions of the science of nutrition to human well-being is in pointing out the benefit of certain foods under certain pathological conditions. Meat has been one of the last foods to be studied in relation to certain diseases. 


Meat and anemia. 


It has been said, "There has been but little significant advancement in the therapy of pernicious anemia from the time that Addison described it in 1855 until the publication in 1926 of the discovery that liver contains a principle which stimulates red blood cell formation." This discovery, after three-quarters of a century without any real progress having been made, ranks in importance with the discovery of insulin. 


The work of Minot and Murphy with human subjects was based on experimental work with dogs by Whipple and co-workers. Whipple's work showed that an animal makes good its losses after a severe hemorrhage much more rapidly if given an abundance of meat, and more recent observations have demonstrated the great value of liver in this respect. 


The application of these findings to the ordinary anemias of adult life and growing children should be apparent. The use of liver, kidney, muscle meat, certain fruits, and green vegetables is necessary. These findings also have an application to the anemias of infancy. Whipple has shown that whole milk is far from having a favorable reaction to blood building. The infant who has developed anemia should have such foods as beef juice, scraped beef, egg yolk, spinach, prunes, and oatmeal along with the milk. 


Recent experiments have shown that an extract made from the stomach of hog is also of great value in the treatment and cure of pernicious anemia. The studies with experimental animals has resulted in saving untold numbers of human lives and the work of Whipple was the first step toward one of the great problems of the medical world.

Jan 16, 1933

​

Open Entry:

​

Ten Lessons on Meat - for use in schools

1/16/33

"Pellagra is a disease which occurs in areas where the diet is lacking in fresh meats, milk, eggs, and leafy vegetables."

Meat and pellagra. 


Pellagra is a disease which occurs in areas where the diet is lacking in fresh meats, milk, eggs, and leafy vegetables. An adequate diet is the only effective method of prevention and cure of this disease. In early studies of this disease the cause was attributed to lack of sufficient protein of good biological value. The preventive action of fresh beef, which furnishes excellent protein, no doubt was responsible for this conclusion drawn by the late Dr. Goldberger and his co-workers. 


Further study by these workers in which a larger intake of protein in the form of casein failed completely to prevent the disease demonstrated that the potency of the beef was not due entirely to its protein. The results of such experiments have been interpreted as indicating that an unrecognized dietary essential is concerned with the prevention of pellagra. 


This factor, designated as P-P, according to these workers, might be effective with little or possibly no cooperation from the protein factor. The pellagra-preventive activity of yeast extract gave further evidence of the existence of this factor P-P. [65]  


Later studies associated pellagra-preventive factor P-P with vitamin B and revealed the multiple nature of vitamin B. Factor P-P, now designated vitamin G of the vitamin B complex, is contained in dried lean beef. Its presence in dried beefsteak and liver also has been demonstrated. The work of Hoagland and Snider has shown its presence in several dried tissues of beef, pork, and lamb. Eecent work by Sherman and Derbigny1  points to the possibility that both protein shortage and vitamin G deficiency may be concerned in the development of pellagra-like symptoms. They say: "In so far as the symptoms of shortage of vitamin G are regarded as pellagralike, such a vitamin theory of the disease should not preclude recognition of the possibility that the protein supply may also have a significant bearing on the pellagra problem." 


Day2  reports determinations of vitamin G in fresh tissues of beef and veal. This work found beef heart to be three times as potent as beef round steak; beef kidney 8-10 times; beef liver 10 times; veal round steak showed slightly higher concentration of vitamin G than beef round, and veal liver and kidney were about the same as beef kidney. 


From this study, as well as others, the potency of the glandular organs is shown to be higher in vitamin G content than the muscle tissues. When a diet consisting largely of salt pork and starchy foods is changed to one in which lean meats, milk and legumes are abundant, pellagra disappears.

Jan 17, 1933

​

Open Entry:

​

Ten Lessons on Meat - For Use in Schools

1/17/33

Although the book doesn't implicate meat in causing disease "in many cases meat has a place in the treatment of the very diseases which it was once said to cause.", it does introduce an error whereby indigestible cellulose needs to be eaten in order to enhance bulk of the stool. "Meat, since it is so completely digested, furnishes very little of the bulk necessary to regulate body functions."

Meat in Bright's disease. 


The present diet in Bright's disease is in striking contrast to the theory of diet formerly held. An abundance of protein is the rule in the new diet. Dr. McLester says: "It was the custom to think only in terms of protein catabolism and of the harmful effects of its end-products, and consequently the patient was told to eat no meat. Now attention is directed to the anabolic influences of protein, its upbuilding effects and beneficial influence on repair processes, and the patient is told to take liberal amounts of this essential foodstuff." s 


Meat does not cause disease. 


In the past many erroneous beliefs were held regarding meat as a contributing cause to disease. Meat has been blamed for a long list of diseases such as kidney trouble, rheumatism, high blood pressure, cancer, hardening of the arteries, gout, etc. In the light of the newer knowledge of foods and diet through careful scientific investigation, these old theories not only have been discarded, but in many cases meat has a place in the treatment of the very diseases which it was once said to cause. 


Meat lacks bulk. 


Meat, since it is so completely digested, furnishes very little of the bulk necessary to regulate body functions. If the entire diet were made up of food lacking in bulk, there would be difficulty in eliminating waste products from the body. It is essential, therefore, to eat plenty of leafy vegetables and fruit with their frame-work of indigestible cellulose as well as for the nutrients that make these foods valuable.

Jul 27, 1933

​

Open Entry:

​

A Letter by Mrs Griest, a nurse in Alaska

7/27/33

The first case of cancer, a 25 pound liver, is found in an Eskimo native.

Dr. Greist's reply to my letter was to the effect that the man I asked about had not died in hospital, that there had been no post mortem, and that the cause of death was unknown. Thus it was not until 1957, some twenty-two years later, that I discovered I had failed to get the information I needed, because I had asked a loaded question and the doctor had answered me literally. I had asked whether a certain specified man had died of cancer and the answer I got was that, in this specified case, the cause of death was unknown. Meantime it was known to Dr. Greist that another Eskimo had died of cancer. From the records of his hospital it is apparent that a cancer patient died there of the disease on July 27, 1933.

Because this was the first known malignancy death in northern Alaska, occurring forty-nine years after Leavitt began his search on the north coast, I shall set down all the details of which I feel sure.

When I took up again those inquiries which led to the writing of this book, an early step was to attempt to revive my correspondence with Dr. Greist, who had resigned his medical missionary position in 1936 and retired to his Indiana home at 318 North Bluff Street, Monticello. The reply came from Mrs. Greist, for her husband had died two years before.

In a letter dated February 19, 1957, Mrs. Greist explains that she remembers nothing of a disagreement between her husband and Mr. Brower on the cause of anybody's death, and suggests that if there was such a dispute it would be outside her sphere unless the man died in hospital or unless for some reason there was s post mortem, at which, in her capacity as head nurse, she would have assisted or at least have been told about it. Then Mrs. Greist continues:

“... I do remember nursing a case of cancer of the liver of an old man who came to Barrow from far to the eastward. After a week or two he died and Dr. Greist and I held a post mortem. We were then satisfied it was cancer ...”

This was all Mrs. Greist was able to say from memory, except that northern Alaska's first identified cancer illness and death came during some year early in the 1930's. But when she learned that her testimony was intended for publication, along with other testimonies, she instituted a search and finally discovered precise dates for this case. She wrote me on August 30, 1958:

“After three days and late nights reading through three years of my diary that I kept in the North, I found what you wish to know about the cancer case. On July 27, 1933, at 7:45 A.M. Jobe passed. I have recorded the fact that Lee, Helen and I helped Dr. Greist with the autopsy. [We found] an immense cancer of the liver; we guessed the weight at 25 or 30 pounds ... Helen is dead; Lee should remember [the cancer victim's] full [Eskimo] name... Lee is head of the native store at Barrow now.”

Mrs. Greist followed up this second letter by lending me a handwritten diary dating from January 1, 1933, to December 31 of that year. Into this she has freshly written, opposite the entry for July 5: “The day Jobe came in.” The entry says: “Jobe came in with obstruction of the bowels; very bad shape.”

The diary for July 17 says: “Old Jobe much worse; going to die ... Up on duty till 4:00 A.M., did not sleep till 4:30.”

In a further recent entry Mrs. Greist indicates on the margin for July 27 that here is the crucial passage of her informal, private diary. Insofar as applicable the passage reads:

“Helen came and called me at 3:00 A.M. as she thought Jobe was passing ... but he did not die until 7:45 A.M. Both girls were very sleepy so we let them sleep ... Worked all day; cleaned some in the operating room and clinic. Helped Dr. with the autopsy on Jobe (Helen, Lee and I). An immense cancer of the liver ... it must have weighed 25 to 30 pounds. Helen and I washed and dressed Jobe for burial."

Apart from assuring me that this was the first case known to herself, or to Dr. Greist, of death from cancer by an Eskimo native from the north coast of Alaska, Mrs. Greist had little pertinent information on the case of Jobe. He was an elderly man. Whether he had worked on shipboard (thus living a good deal European style) she cannot say.

Jan 1, 1934

​

Open Entry:

​

Dr. L. A. White Letter

1/1/34

Dr. L. A. White practiced in Alaska and rarely found hypertensive, arteriosclerotic, diabetes, cancer, strokes, or coronary heart disease among the natives between 1934-1948.

Dr. L. A. White of 642 Eugene Medical Center, Eugene, Oregon, wrote me on February 21, 1958:

“... It has been almost 17 years since I practiced in Alaska. I was at Unalaska [Aleutian Islands] 1934-48, having previously spent 17 months at Metlakatla [Alaska Panhandle], then several months in '39 at Klawock [Panhandle]; finally one and a half years at Bethel [Lower Kuskokwim]. My work led me to these conclusions: (1) hypertensive and arteriosclerotic diseases were practically nonexistent among the native peoples; (2) diabetes was extremely rare; (3) malignant disease was extremely rare — in fact, I had only one proven case (Bethel, 1940). I saw no strokes nor coronary heart disease ...”

Jul 14, 1934

​

Open Entry:

​

High Carbohydrate Diets and Insulin Efficiency

7/14/34

Dr Himsworth explains why he thinks high carb diets are good for diabetics - and pays special attention to how carbohydrate sensitizes the pancreas to release more insulin, while also speaking towards insulin resistance. His 11 page science article is pretty interesting.

Physicians were slow to appreciate that insulin allowed the proportion of carbohydrate in the diet to be increased, for, as Himsworth said, ‘a well-founded theory directs that the carbohydrates in the diabetic’s diet must be curtailed if health is to be preserved’. On the other hand, as he continued, ‘a brilliant piece of clinical empiricism produces irrefutable proof that a liberal allowance of carbohydrate acts favourably on the diabetic’s health’ [17]. This empiricism began in 1926, when a high carbohydrate diet was first shown to improve glucose tolerance in healthy individuals [18].

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00125-008-1203-9


Himsworth recommended a high-carbohydrate diet to treat diabetes. Professor Edwin Gale has noted:

He demonstrated that injected insulin produced a greater hypoglycaemic response in individuals treated with the high carbohydrate diet, thus demonstrating that diet could influence insulin sensitivity. The high carbohydrate diet worked because it allowed the flow of glucose to the tissues to be maintained at a lower head of pressure by making people more sensitive to their own insulin.[5]


HIGH CARBOHYDRATE DIETS AND INSULIN EFFICIENCY 

BY H. P. HIMSWORTH, M.D., M.R.C.P. BEIT MEMORIAL RESEARCH FELLOW; ASSISTANT, MEDICAL UNIT, UNIVERSITY COLLEGE HOSPITAL, LONDON 

During the last four years the use of diets containing a relatively large quantity of carbohydrate has become more and more common in the treatment of diabetes mellitus. When these diets were first introduced they were received with many theoretical objections, but their undeniable success rapidly compelled their serious consideration and encouraged their increasing acceptance. This divergence between theoretical objection anid practical success is no minor discrepancy capable of easy adjustment after careful revision of the data, but a definite conflict between two diametrically opposed conclusions. 


On the one hand, a well-founded theory directs that the carbohydrates in the diabetic's diet must be curtailed if health is to be preserved; whilst, on the other, a brilliant piece of clinical empiricism produces irrefutable proof that a liberal allowance of carbohydrate acts favourably on the diabetic's health. At present it may be said that the thepretical objections are securely established, not only on a logical sequence of experimental results, but also on the accumulated clinical experience of diabetes mellitus before the introduction of insulin whilst the beneficial effects attending the use of high carbohydrate diets are inexplicable either by any known physiological or pathological mechanism, or on the basis of previous clinical experience. A probable clue as to the nature of the discrepancy is suggested by a consideration of the chronological relation of the conflicting views. The good results following the use of high carbohydrate diets were not discovered until after the introduction of insulin treatment. This suggests that there exists in the body a mechanism capable of stimulating the utilization of carbohydrate, but which cannot exert its action in the absence of an adequate supply of insulin. It was with the object of searching for this mechanism that the present work was undertaken, and the employment of healthy men as subjects for the search was dictated by the supposition that it would only be possible to detect the unknown mechanism in subjects possessing the normal supply of insulin. 


Theoretical Objections to High Carbohydrate Diet 


Before discussing the present research it is first necessary to glance at the work upon which the theoretical objections to the use of high carbohydrate diets in diabetes are based. For a long time it has been known that the excessive consumption of carbohydrate by the diabetic results in deterioration of his clinical condition. It was not, however, -until a few years before the discovery of insulin that light was thrown, by the work of F. M. Allen and his collaborators, on the mechanism of this unfavourable clinical change. Allen studied the effect of diet upon the health of partially depancreatized dogs, and summed up his results by saying:


"Dogs which have lost a certain amount of pancreatic tissue will become diabetic irrespective of diet. Dogs which retain a sufficient amount of pancreatic tissue will never become diabetic irrespective of diet. But between these two groups is an intermediate group. On an Eskimo diet they may be found to live in health. On a Hindu diet they soon go down to fatal diabetes." 


Thus if sufficient pancreas is removed from a dog so that it is on the borderline of pancreatic diabetes the animal lives, if it receives a low carbohydrate diet, and the blood sugar remains low and glycosuria does not occur. But if such an animal is given a diet rich in carbohydrates the full clinical and chemical picture of pancreatic diabetes appears, and the animal rapidly dies. Allen further confirmed the work of other investigators, showing that, as a general rule, once pancreatic diabetes has been induced in these dogs by excessive intake of carbohydrates, then a return to the low carbohydrate diet will not cure the condition. It would appear that ingestion of excess of carbohydrate overstrained the remaining pancreatic tissue so as to produce a permanent degree of degeneration. In the partially depancreatized dogs which died of the diabetes thus induced, histological examination of their pancreatic tissue revealed hydropic degeneration of the ,B cells of the islets of Langerhans, and Allen emphasized that this was also found in the pancreas of the patient dying in diabetic coma. As by this time the probability of the insular tissue's secreting an "anti-diabetic hormone" was generally accepted, conclusions from Allen's work were easily drawn. In the partially depancreatized dog excess of dietary carbohydrate, by producing a raised blood sugar, causes overstrain of the islets in the remaining pancreatic tissue; under this strain the cells break down and eventually are unable to secrete sufficient hormone to prevent the development of pancreatic diabetes. At death the /B cells of the islets are in a state of hydropic degeneration; the pancreas from the diabetic dead of his disease shows similar lesions; therefore to preserve life in the diabetic the islet cells must be guarded against overstrain by maintaining the blood sugar at a low level by restriction of carbohydrates in the diet. The Allen diet--and the theoretical objections-are based on these conclusions.


Clinical Significance of the Results 

The results recorded in this paper carry us on our way towards the explanation of Allen's glucose equivalent of insulin. The reason behind the observation that the more carbohydrate ingested the greater the amount retained in the body by each unit of insulin is that the more carbohydrate eaten the more sensitive the organism becomes to each unit. Hence the paradox of the glucose insulin equivalent. It will be remembered that Allen's experiments were carried out on depancreatized dogs, and thus demonstrate that such a dog under the stimulus of the administration of carbohydrate is capable of developing an increasing sensitivity to insulin. My results show that the giving of carbohydrate raises the efficiency of. both injected and pancreatic insulin in the normal subject. It only remains to prove that carbohydrate has the same action in the diabetic and the explanation of the beneficial effect of high carbohydrate diets in these patients has been achieved. Ellis has recently supplied this proof. To diabetics needing large doses of insulin he gave glucose by mouth and small doses of insulin every hour. A remarkable increase in insulin efficiency resulted. Despite the ingestion of constant large amounts of glucose the dose of insulin required to restrain the blood sugar within normal limits decreased progressively. These results show that some diabetics, though possibly not all, are capable of developing a heightened sensitivity to insulin under the stimulus of carbohydrate ingestion. Thus the improvement of diabetic patients on a high carbohydrate diet is to be ascribed not to the greater stimulation, and consequent overstrain, of their insulin-secreting tissue by the excessive intake of carbohydrate, but rather to the rendering of the diabetic more susceptible both to his pancreatic and the injected insulin. The result is that each unit of insulin available accounts for a greater amount of carbohydrate. This, necessarily, by allowing a more economical utilization of the insulin secreted, reduces the demand of the body for insulin, with a consequent easing of the strain on the diseased islet cells. By thus lighteing the burden on the cells which remain capable of function it is possible that we aid their conservation as healthy tissue, and save rather than squander the patient's own pancreatic resources. If the augmentation of a diabetic's sensitivity to insulln is of importance in the balanced state, it is of much greater importance in the state of coma. It is well known that hundreds of units of insulin may be given in this condition with little effect on the blood sugar, when in the same diabetic after recovery 20 or 30 units will produce hypoglycaemic symptoms. Many comatose and precomatose patients seem to be relatively insensitive to insulin, and any measure directed to raise their sensitivity would appear to be of benefit. To this end glucose should be administered in large doses. The success of treatment based on this principle I have recorded previously, and the method has since been strongly recommended by Lawrence." A growing number of cases of diabetes are being. reported in which the patients for no ascertainable reason are found to be resistant to insulin. In one such case doses as large as 1,600 units of insulin a day had no effect on the blood sugar. It is possible that these cases may be explained by an almost complete absence of the factor making for susceptibility. In contradistinction to' these insulin-resistant diabetics, cases of spontaneous hypoglycaemia in which no hypertrophy or tumour of the islet cells can be found are continually being recorded. In such patients it is theoretically possible that the hypoglycaemia may be the outcome not of hyperinsulinism, but of the development of a state of a greatly heightened susceptibility lo insulin secreted by the pancreas. Finally, I would suggest the possibility of the existence of a type of diabetes due not to diminished secretion of insulin by the pancreas, but to a greater or less impairment of the organism's susceptibility to insulin. In such a case, although the output of endogenous insulin may be normal in quantity, the diminution or absence of the factor which is concerned in rendering the patient susceptible to insulin would produce a result identical with that of impaired production of insulin-namely, the clinical picture of diabetes mellitus.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2444943/pdf/brmedj07161-0009.pdf

Jan 1, 1935

​

Open Entry:

​

Diet, delusion and diabetes

1/1/35

The invention of insulin means that doctors can allow type 1 diabetics to eat more carbohydrates, apparently because it greatly increased their well-being because a low carb diet is apparently miserable. Dr Rabinowitch was prescribing diets with as much as 400 grams of carbohydrates!

"The benefit was dramatic, next only to insulin in the minds of its recipients, for it combined greatly increased well-being with escape from the miseries of an endless low carbohydrate diet.


The carbohydrate component soon escalated, and a typical diet prescribed by the Canadian physician Israel Rabinowitch in the mid-1930s might contain 2,230 calories, 400 g of carbohydrate, 50 g of fat and 70 g of protein, with 67% of energy derived from carbohydrate [20]."


Meanwhile, in the interest of showing both sides, a vegan site says this is a good thing:

https://www.wholefoodplantbaseddiet.com/tag/dr-i-m-rabinowitch-and-diabetes/#footnote_1_6199


In a seminal paper published in 1935 2 , Dr Rabinowitch demonstrated that simple dietary changes (increasing the ratio of complex carbohydrates while reducing calorie intake) could reverse type 2 diabetes.

In his summary he states:

“I believe that in the data presented here there is incontrovertible evidence that the high carbohydrate-low calorie diet is more effective in controlling diabetes than all other methods of treatment hitherto reported…it is, therefore, more economical from the point of view of the cost of insulin…”

Jan 1, 1935

Vilhjalmur Stefansson

Open Entry:

​

Adventures in Diet

1/1/35

Stefansson describes his experiences living with the Eskimo and eating an all meat diet.

In 1906 I went to the Arctic with the food tastes and beliefs of the average American. By 1918, after eleven years living as an Eskimo among Eskimos, I had learned things which caused me to shed most of those beliefs. Ten years later I began to realize that what I had learned was going to influence decisively the sciences of medicine and dietetics. However, what finally impressed the scientists and converted many during the last two or three years, was a series of confirmatory experiments upon myself and a colleague performed at Bellevue Hospital, New York City, under the supervision of a committee representing several universities and other organizations.

Not so long ago, the following dietetic beliefs were common: To be healthy you need a varied diet, composed of elements from both the animal and vegetable kingdoms. You got tired of and eventually felt a revulsion against things if you had to eat them often. This latter belief was supported by stories of people who through force of circumstances had been compelled, for instance, to live for two weeks on sardines and crackers and who, according to the stories, had sworn that so long as they lived they never would touch sardines again. The Southerners had it that nobody can eat a quail a day for thirty days.

Jan 1, 1935

​

Open Entry:

​

Religion and Science Association, The Deluge Story in Stone: A History of the Flood Theory of Geology

1/1/35

In 1935, Price and Dudley Joseph Whitney (a rancher who had co-founded the Lindcove Community Bible Church, and now followed Price) founded the Religion and Science Association (RSA). They aimed to resolve disagreements among fundamentalists with "a harmonious solution" which would convert them all to flood geology.

In 1935, Price and Dudley Joseph Whitney (a rancher who had co-founded the Lindcove Community Bible Church, and now followed Price) founded the Religion and Science Association (RSA). They aimed to resolve disagreements among fundamentalists with "a harmonious solution" which would convert them all to flood geology. Most of the organising group were Adventists, others included conservative Lutherans with similarly literalist beliefs. Bryon C. Nelson of the Norwegian Lutheran Church of America had included Price's geological views in a 1927 book, and in 1931 published The Deluge Story in Stone: A History of the Flood Theory of Geology, which described Price as the "one very outstanding advocate of the Flood" of the century. The first public RSA conference in March 1936 invited various fundamentalist views, but opened up differences between the organisers on the antiquity of creation and on life before Adam. The RSA went defunct in 1937, and a dispute continued between Price and Nelson, who now viewed Creation as occurring over 100,000 years previously.[50]

May 1, 1935

​

Open Entry:

​

May 1935 issue of The Canadian Medical Association Journal (Toronto)

5/1/35

Dr Urquhart has not yet met with a single case of cancer in the seven years of his practice, the Eskimos of the Canadian Eastern Arctic were still living substantially on their native foods.

 A health survey made in 1935, with cancer as one of its focal points is described in an article by the senior investigator of the survey, Dr. I. N. Rabinowitch of Montreal, appearing in the May 1935 issue of The Canadian Medical Association Journal (Toronto).

“Two different interests prompted this investigation. The purpose of the Canadian Government was to determine the general health of the Eskimos; whether contact with civilization is causing their deterioration; and, if so, the causes. Quite frankly, this was not the writer's interest ... His interest was primarily in the alleged absence of diabetes, cancer, and arteriosclerosis, and the possible relationship between such absence and the peculiar dietary habits of the people.”

Dr. Rabinowitch found in 1935 that the Eskimos of the northern coastal section of the Canadian eastern Arctic were still living substantially on their native foods, although they were in some places eating enough carbohydrates to materially affect their previously good teeth. Of diabetes and arteriosclerosis he found only slight indication. Of cancer he says on page 493:

“In the western Arctic [from Alaska to Coronation Gulf] Dr. Urquhart has not yet met with a single case of cancer in the seven years of his practice. Cancer must be very rare in the eastern Arctic also. I saw one suspicious case ...” [Dr. Rabinowitch thought it was probably not cancer.]

Gary Taubes wrote in his new book The Case For Keto a paragraph that I want to dedicate this database towards:

​

"I did this obsessive research because I wanted to know what was reliable knowledge about the nature of a healthy diet. Borrowing from the philosopher of science Robert Merton, I wanted to know if what we thought we knew was really so. I applied a historical perspective to this controversy because I believe that understanding that context is essential for evaluating and understanding the competing arguments and beliefs. Doesn’t the concept of “knowing what you’re talking about” literally require, after all, that you know the history of what you believe, of your assumptions, and of the competing belief systems and so the evidence on which they’re based?

This is how the Nobel laureate chemist Hans Krebs phrased this thought in a biography he wrote of his mentor, also a Nobel laureate, Otto Warburg: “True, students sometimes comment that because of the enormous amount of current knowledge they have to absorb, they have no time to read about the history of their field. But a knowledge of the historical development of a subject is often essential for a full understanding of its present-day situation.” (Krebs and Schmid 1981.)

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Reddit's r/Ketoscience
bottom of page