
Total Entries: 1046
Select one of the above filters
Year Filter:
Fat consumption varied wildly between different groups.
In 1964, F.W. Lowenstein, a medical officer for the World Health Organization in Geneva, collected every study he could find on men who were virtually free of heart disease, and concluded that their fat consumption varied wildly, from about 7 percent of total calories among Benedictine monks and the Japanese to 65 percent among Somalis. And there was every number in between: Mayans checked in with 26 percent, Phillippines with 14 percent, the Gabonese with 18 percent, and black slaves on the island of St. Kitts with 17 percent. The type of fat also varied dramatically, from cottonseed and seasme oil (vegetable fats) eaten by Buddhist monks to the gallons of milk (all animal fat) drunk by the Masai. Most other groups ate some kind of mixture of vegetable and animal fats. One could only conclude from thees findings that any link between dietary fat and heart disease was, at best, weak and unreliable.
- Nina Teicholz - The Big Fat Surprise - page 56
Harvard Nutritionist Jean Mayer writes to 35 million people that low carb diet is "the equivalent of mass murder."
Jean Mayer, one of the “greats” of nutrition science, said in 1965, in the colourful language that has characterised arguments over diet, that prescribing a diet restricted in carbohydrates to the public was “the equivalent of mass murder.”

Jean Mayer, dean of Tufts University, argued that obesity was caused by a lack of exercise, a view that is now consensus, yet wrote “These mice will make fat out of their food under the most unlikely circumstances, even when half starved.”
This observation about the physiological nature of obesity was made decades ago, perhaps centuries ago. The most conspicuous examples are animals (as Astwood noted with his “consider the pig” point) and the animal models of obesity that nutritionists and obesity researchers have studied since the late 1930s. Indeed, researchers would occasionally admit that it’s clearly true about animals and animal models of obesity—that some animals get fat effectively independent of how much they eat and even when they eat no more than lean animals—but then somehow reject its relevance to humans on the basis that everyone knows that humans get fat because they eat too much. Their devotion to their energy balance thinking and to its implications was so great that they couldn’t escape it.
Take, for instance, Jean Mayer, the most influential American nutritionist in the 1960s and into the ’70s. Mayer started his research career at Harvard in the late 1940s and then moved on to become dean of Tufts University. The nutrition school at Tufts was later named after him. As a nutritionist, Mayer got some things right and many things wrong, as scientists often do, even the best of them. He spent the later years of his life arguing that people with obesity get that way because they don’t exercise enough. Our current obsession with physical activity is largely rooted in Mayer’s proselytizing in the 1970s. But at the beginning of his career in the 1950s, he studied a strain of obese mice. “These mice,” he wrote, “will make fat out of their food under the most unlikely circumstances, even when half starved.”
That’s the nature of overweight and obesity. That’s what it means to have a “compulsory tendency toward marked overweight due to abnormal accumulation of fat.” Mayer’s mice did not get fat by overeating. They got fat by eating. Half-starving them didn’t make them lean. It only made them hungry and slightly less fat. So let’s redefine what we mean by obesity. People with obesity are not thin people who couldn’t control their appetites (for whatever reason, psychological or neurobiological) and therefore ate too much. They’re people whose bodies are trying to accumulate excess fat even when they’re half-starved. The drive to accumulate fat is the problem, and it’s the difference between the fat and the lean. The hunger and the cravings, and then the failures and the sins, as Astwood suggested, are the results. This observation should be blindingly obvious to anyone who has ever had a weight problem, who fattens easily. Those who fatten easily are profoundly different from those who don’t and may have been from the womb onward. Their physiology is different; their hormonal and metabolic responses to foods are different. Their bodies want to store calories as fat; the bodies of their lean friends don’t. In George Bernard Shaw’s play Misalliance, written in 1909–10, his character John Tarleton puts it this way: “It’s constitutional. No matter how little you eat you put on flesh if you’re made that way.” Shaw, via Tarleton, may have been exaggerating slightly, but that’s as good a way to capture the simplicity of the idea as any. If these people want to be relatively lean and healthy, if such a thing is possible, they have to eat differently. There may be foods they cannot eat. Foods that make them fat may not make their lean friends fat.
Gary Taubes. The Case for Keto: Rethinking Weight Control and the Science and Practice of Low-Carb/High-Fat Eating (Kindle Locations 697-700). Knopf. Kindle Edition.
AHA spreads heart clinics across the country through new act in Congress.
In 1965, the AHA president worked closely with Congress to establish the Regional Medical Programs Service as part of the NHI, which, through a contract with the AHA, went through an elaborate process to set up standards for cardiovascular care across the country.
Ten months later, in October 1965, from legislation introduced by Senator Lister Hill of Alabama and Representative Oren Harris of Arkansas, the Heart Disease, Cancer and Stroke Amendments became law (Public Law 89-239). The act authorized the establishment and maintenance of Regional Medical Programs. Its purpose was " to encourage and assist in the establishment of regional cooperative arrangements among medical schools, research institutions, and hospitals for research and training, including continuing education, and for related demonstration of patient care . . . . " (Sec. 900, Public Law 89-239). Fifty-six regions were established, covering the nation, including Puerto Rico. In December 1965, the National Advisory Council on Regional Medical Programs met to initiate the program, and in February, Dr. Robert Q. Marston was appointed first Director of the Division of RMP, an NIH office. Dr. Marston served as Associate Director of NIH, under Director James A. Shannon. The National Advisory Council awarded the first planning grants in April 1966, followed by the first operational grants ten months later, in February 1967. By the end of that year, sixty-one Regional Medical Programs had been designated and four of these were operational. Most programs were located at or near university medical schools.
Despite these issues, however, the Oslo experiment is remembered only for the success of its cholesterol-lowering diet.
The fourth frequently cited diet trial “proving” the diet-heart hypothesis was known as the Oslo study, conducted in the early 1960s.
Paul Leren, a medical doctor in Oslo, Norway, selected 412 middle-aged men who had suffered a first heart attack (rates of heart disease among men in Oslo had skyrocketed from 1945 to 1961) and divided his subjects into two groups. One group followed a traditional Norwegian diet, which Leren describes as high in cheese, milk, meat, and bread as well as vegetables and fruit in season—altogether, 40 percent fat. The second group undertook a “cholesterol-lowering” diet featuring lots of fish and soybean oil but very little meat and no whole milk or cream. In all, the diets contained about the same amount of fat, but in the “cholesterol-lowering” diet most of the fat was polyunsaturated.
Leren chose to study men who had already had a heart attack, in part because such men tend to be highly motivated to stick to a doctor-prescribed diet. This was especially valuable since, as Leren acknowledged, the special high-vegetable-oil diet was received “not with enthusiasm,” and some of the men felt weakened and nauseated by it. The other advantage of working with such a population and why post-heart-attack men are so often chosen for these types of trials is that these men are more likely to have another heart attack soon, and so researchers will have enough “events” to generate statistically significant results.
The experiment lasted five years, and in 1966, Leren published his findings. Like all these other large trials, his diet had successfully lowered the men’s serum cholesterol, in this case by about 13 percent more than the controls. Fatal heart attacks were definitely down in the dieting group: ten versus twenty-three among the controls, which was an impressive result. However, a major wrench in the experiment, and one that has gone unnoticed because until recently no one was looking for it, was that in addition to saturated animal fats, the control group was eating a great deal of hard margarine and hydrogenated fish oils, then staples of the Norwegian diet, amounting to nearly half a cup of trans fats per day. This was many times more than the average American was eating when the Food and Drug Administration deemed trans fats dangerous enough to put them on food labels. The experimental diet, which sought to maximize polyunsaturated soybean oil, did not contain trans fats, and this was a significant difference that might easily have affected the outcome. Also, the experimental group, following a public health campaign of the time, cut out tobacco use by 45 percent more than the control group, a large difference that the investigators could not explain but which alone could have accounted for most of the difference in heart attack numbers. Despite these issues, however, the Oslo experiment is remembered only for the success of its cholesterol-lowering diet.
-Nina Teicholz - page 78
Malhotra demonstrates a difference in heart disease rates between Northern Indians eating saturated fats and Southern Indians eating refined carbs and seed oils.
Several studies, notably those of Keys et al. (1958), have suggested that dietary fats are a major factor in the etiology of ischmmic heart disease. It is suggested that the liability to develop ischsmic heart disease increases with a rise in the total consumption of dietary fats, or that a higher consumption of saturated fatty acids increases this liability. On the other hand, there are several careful epidemiological studies from many countries, such as the statistical review by Yudkin (1957), which failed to find even a clear-cut correlation between fat consumption and mortality from ischemic heart disease. In India the consumption of fats (Indian Council for Medical Research, 1964) and also the pattern of diets and eating (Malhotra, 1964) differ from place to place, and a study of the geographical aspects of myocardial infarction with reference to dietary differences could, therefore, be worth while. The study reported in this paper stems from such an attempt.
Perambur (Madras) and Alavakkot, both in South India, show the highest incidence rates for acute myocardial infarction as compared with the centres in the North, such as Ferozepur, Jhansi, or Delhi. The incidence is 7 times higher in Perambur (South India) than in Ferozepur (North India). These geographical trends are also reflected in the admissions for acute myocardial infarction expressed as a percentage of all admissions (Table I).
Fats.
The fat consumption in the South is 8-19 times less than in the Punjab (Indian Council for Medical Research, 1964), the average daily amount in the case of railway sweepers, investigated by us, being 7 g. of seed oils, such as groundnut or sesame oil. The proportion of calories from fat is 3j per cent of a total of 2400 calories. In the North, on the other hand, average daily consumption of 75 g. mainly ghee and other milk fats and to some extent of vegetable seed oil, such as mustard oil or vanaspathi, provides 23 per cent of calories from fats out of a total of 2800 calories. In the higher income groups the daily fat intake in the North is even higher, being 70-190 g. against 10-30 g. in the South (Padmavati, 1962). Less obvious, but equally important, are the differences in the chemical composition of fats used by these disparate population groups. Milk, ghee, and fermented milk products, which are the main sources of fats in the Punjab and Rajasthan, contain a large proportion (43%') of short-chain lower fatty acids (Hilditch, 1949). The relative proportion of lower fatty acids in the seed oils, such as groundnut or sesame (gingelly) oil is much smaller; and in these the longchain oleic, linoleic, and palmitic acids are prominent (Nicholls, 1961). The degree of saturation of the fatty acids in the dietary fats of the South Indians versus North Indians also shows big differences. Thus, while the North Indians largely consume fats containing saturated fatty acids, the South Indians eat fat in which the poly-unsaturated fatty acids have a preponderance: the poly-unsaturated fatty acid content of the South Indian seed oils is 45 per cent against 2 per cent in the North Indian ghee and other milk fats (Indian Council for Medical Research, 1963).

Elizabeth Arnajarnek feeds a pre-chewed morsel of caribou meat to her baby at a camp on the Barren Grounds in 1966. The Inuit gather thousands of duck eggs and eat them raw or hard-boiled. They store them for the winter.
Noises and voices drifted through the fog; the creak and groan of tide-moved ice; the honking of Canada geese; the plaintive calling of red-throated loons; the lilting song of snow buntings; the haunting, mellow woodwind crooning of courting eider drakes.
Early next morning, the fog lifted. We climbed a hill topped by an inukshuk, an ancient, roughly man-shaped Inuit stone marker, and gazed across the sea dotted with dark granite islands bathed in the golden light of dawn.
Our boats full of pots, pails, zinc and plastic wash basins, and large wooden crates, we set out to raid the holms, the rocky islets that are the eiders' favorite nesting places. Men, women, and children stumbled across the algae-slippery coastal rocks of each islet, scrambled up the sheer ice foot, and then spread, screaming with glee, across the island as dozens of eiders, sometimes hundreds, rushed and clattered off their nests. Each nest was lined with a thick, soft layer of brownish gray-flecked eiderdown and contained, on the average, four large olive eggs. The Inuit took the eggs but left the down; traditionally they dressed in furs and had no use for down. Since it was early in the season, most ducks had just laid their eggs.
We rushed from island to island and collected eggs all day, and at night we feasted on them. The children, impatient, pricked many and sucked them dry. The adults preferred them hard-boiled. They made a filling meal; each egg, in volume, equals nearly two hen's eggs, and many Inuit ate six to ten at each meal. The albumen of the hard-boiled eider egg is a smooth, gleaming white, the yolk a vivid orange. The taste is rich and rather oily.
In a week we visited dozens of islets and amassed thousands of eggs. The Inuit also shot at least a hundred ducks and several seals. It seemed amazing that these yearly raids had not decimated the ducks. But they were made so early in the season that most of the robbed ducks probably laid another clutch of eggs.
Killiktee explained to me that in earlier days a taboo forbade the Inuit to camp on eider islands. They visited the islets and took the eggs, but they camped, as we did, only on the largest islands, where few ducks nest, thus avoiding prolonged disturbances in the breeding areas. The ducks, Killiktee said, seemed just as numerous now as sixty years ago when he had first visited the Savage Islands as a boy. Polar bears sometimes swim to the islands, kill all the ducks they can, and eat the eggs. One year, Killiktee said, while the Inuit were on holms, collecting eggs, a polar bear came to camp and robbed their stores. He ate at least a thousand eggs and crushed the rest, leaving a gooey mess upon the beach. Killiktee laughed, amused and without rancor. "Happy bear!" he said.
Less lucky was a gosling caught on an islet by one of the girls. She kept it in a Danish cookie tin and tried to make a pet of it. The fluffy yellow bird peeped pathetically and, inevitably, died after a few days. The girl cried, heartbroken, over her dead pet, and then she skinned it and ate it.
All crates were full of eggs, and ducks, seals, and whale meat filled the boats. The fog rolled in again and our boats traveled through a clammy, grayish, eerie emptiness. Killiktee led, the two other boats followed closely. Dark rocks appeared for moments and vanished into the gloomy gray; ice floes loomed up abruptly. Killiktee never hesitated. "How do you know where to go?" I asked. He smiled. "I know," he said. He had traveled along this coast a long lifetime; he had seen it, memorized it, knew every current, every shoal, every danger spot. He stood in the stern like a graven image and guided our boats through the weird gray void of the fog.
In the evening he veered into a bay, a good place, he said, to catch char on the rising tide. The men set nets, the women boiled pots of meat and tea, the children played. Killiktee, tired, lay down on the shore, and moments later he was sound asleep. A dark shape upon the dark, ice-carved granite, he seemed to meld with rock and land.
Back home at Kiijuak, all eggs were carefully examined. The cracked ones we ate soon. The others were placed in large crates and stored in a cool shady cleft among the rocks. They would last the people in our camp well into the winter.
In fall, an Inuk from Lake Harbour passed our camp and took me along to Aberdeen Bay where the people quarry the jade-green soapstone for their carvings. While he had tea and talked with Killiktee, I packed and carried my things to his boat. Killiktee came to the beach. We both felt awkward. Inuit traditionally joyfully greet visitors, but visitors leave in silence and alone with none to see them off. Their language has many words of wisdom, but none for good-bye.
Polyunsaturates are the plus in Mazola
Although we know them as “vegetable oils,” they’re actually pressed mainly from seeds: cottonseeds, rapeseeds, safflower seeds, sunflower seeds, sesame seeds, and corn, as well as from soybeans. We’ve seen how these oils started to become popular for culinary use when the AHA endorsed them for “heart health” in 1961. Having the backing of the country’s highest medical authority on heart disease gave them an enormous boost. “The rush to get aboard the polyunsaturated bandwagon has become a stampede,” gushed the trade publication Food Processing in that same year. New products containing “higher and higher amounts of polyunsaturated oils” included salad dressings, mayonnaise, and margarine. Even breads and rolls were promoted for containing these new oils. Mazola was just one of the manufacturers enthusiastically advertising the potential health benefits of its oils. “Polyunsaturates are the plus in Mazola,” said a magazine ad in 1967.
Gary Taubes wrote in his new book The Case For Keto a paragraph that I want to dedicate this database towards:
"I did this obsessive research because I wanted to know what was reliable knowledge about the nature of a healthy diet. Borrowing from the philosopher of science Robert Merton, I wanted to know if what we thought we knew was really so. I applied a historical perspective to this controversy because I believe that understanding that context is essential for evaluating and understanding the competing arguments and beliefs. Doesn’t the concept of “knowing what you’re talking about” literally require, after all, that you know the history of what you believe, of your assumptions, and of the competing belief systems and so the evidence on which they’re based?
This is how the Nobel laureate chemist Hans Krebs phrased this thought in a biography he wrote of his mentor, also a Nobel laureate, Otto Warburg: “True, students sometimes comment that because of the enormous amount of current knowledge they have to absorb, they have no time to read about the history of their field. But a knowledge of the historical development of a subject is often essential for a full understanding of its present-day situation.” (Krebs and Schmid 1981.)

