top of page

All History

Total Entries: 1046

Select one of the above filters

Year Filter:
Backwards
Recently Added
Clear Year
Search

Jan 1, 1980

​

Open Entry:

​

​

1/1/80

Obesity in US stable between 12-14% since 1960-1980

URL

Jan 1, 1980

​

Open Entry:

​

​

1/1/80

Dietary Guidelines for Americans released : "Avoid too much total fat and SFA"

Event Rich Text

Jun 1, 1980

​

Open Entry:

​

​

6/1/80

NYT exposes ties to meat and eggs and makes diet-heart hypothesis seem truer.

URL

The New York Times essentially took a poll: “at least 18 other health organizations and the Federal Government supported a reduction in fat and cholesterol,” wrote the editors, with only the academy and the American Medical Association on the other side. The diet’s potential costs—an increased heart disease risk from the carbohydrates, an increased risk of cancer from polyunsaturated oils, or a lack of adequate nutrition for children—were not part of the discussion. The Times concluded, “The Federal Government still thinks a prudent person should eat less fat and cholesterol. Unless the academy can authoritatively demonstrate Government error, a prudent person will do just that.”

Here, then, was the new reality: a political decision had yielded a new scientific truth. Contrary to the normal scientific method, which requires that a hypothesis be tested before it can be considered viable, in this case politics short-circuited the process, and an untested hypothesis was elevated as the reigning doctrine, presumed to be right until proven wrong.

For the academy’s report, the death knell was surely sounded on June 1, 1980, when the New York Times ran a front-page story about two board members and their ties to industry: Robert E. Olson, a biochemist at St. Louis University School of Medicine, had consulted for the egg and dairy industries, and Chairman Harper for the meat industry. These accusations were true. But again, corporate food interests were attempting to influence both sides of the debate. At the same time that two board members had been found to have ties to the meat, dairy, and egg industries, two other members of the academy’s board were food company employees, one with the spice maker McCormick and Company, and another with the Hershey Foods Corp. And from the start, the board had been funded by the Nutrition Foundation, whose members included General Foods, Quaker Oats, Heinz Co., and Corn Products Refining Co., among other major food corporations.

Even despite this powerful lobby, the board had stood firm against the new low-cholesterol, low-fat diet recommendations. “Our attitude at the time,” said Chairman Harper unapologetically in an interview when he was eighty-four years old, “was that if you had a competent person who was an adviser to a food company, there was no reason why they shouldn’t serve on the board.”

Jul 1, 1980

​

Open Entry:

​

​

7/1/80

Toward Healthful Diets is trashed by Congress.

URL

The press and public knew little of these widespread entanglements on all sides of the debate. They only picked up the impression that meat packers and egg farmers were corrupt, a view fostered by the press coverage. The health dangers of saturated fats had already come to be taken so much for granted by this point that pro-animal-food voices were presumed to have ulterior motives. Critics called Toward Healthful Diets “conspiratorial” and “slipshod,” and US Representative Fred Richmond of New York stated openly that lobbyists for the food industry “must have been at work here.”

The furor over the report startled academy scientists unaccustomed to this public gnashing of teeth. Philip Handler, head of the academy, told a friend that Toward Healthful Diets received more attention than had all the academy’s numerous other erudite publications in recent years. “We were naïve about the politics,” he said, and quipped, “you lose some, you lose some.”

 

In the summer of 1980, the House and the Senate each held hearings on the report, and the academy’s reputation was raked over the coals. “Without too much doubt, the [House] committee’s intention was to crucify Handler,” judged Science magazine. Indeed, wrote the Washington Post editorial board, the report had “soiled” the board’s and the academy’s reputations for giving “careful scientific advice.” The report had been a rigorous and fair-minded effort and contained far more expert analysis than did Mottern’s, but publicity is powerful, and the widespread disparaging view of the board’s work on the Toward Healthful Diets report has unfortunately endured until today. Because the academy is one of the few scientific groups that provides checks and balances against the work of other authoritative bodies on the subject of nutrition and disease (the others being the NIH, the USDA, and the AHA), the collapse of the academy’s skeptical report on this issue was a significant event, for it left no formal scientific group to weigh in as the opposition.

Dec 6, 1980

John Yudkin

Open Entry:

​

Food for thought.

12/6/80

Dr Yudkin laments that fibre is not essential and that we should turn focus on sugar as cause of diabetes and heart disease.

But it would be unfair to heap all the blame on the media. Commercial interests were quick to see the potential in the recommendation. AlthoughBurkitt's recommendations were based on vegetable fibre, bran has a far higher fibre content than vegetables and bran was a practically worthless by-product of the milling process which, until then, had been thrown away. Now, virtually overnight, it became a highly priced profit maker. Bran is quite inedible - there is no known enzyme in the human body that can digest it. Nevertheless, backed by Burkitt's fibre hypothesis, commercial interests could now promote it as a valuable food. The late John Yudkin, Professor Emeritus of Nutrition and Dietetics at London University, pointed out that 'perhaps one reason for the wide acceptance of the suggestion that fibre is an important, if not essential, dietary component is that it had the enthusiastic support of commercial interests.' He was writing in particular about the
high-bran products, All Bran and Branslim. 

​

 

Sir,--As Dr N H Dyer says in his review of the Royal College of Physicians' report on dietary fibre, fashions change. Perhaps one reason for the wide acceptance of the suggestion that fibre is an important, if not essential, dietary component is that it had the enthuiastic support of commercial interests. A press release from the manufacturers of All-Bran says with dogmatic assurance, "A diet deficient in fibre makes people more prone to diseases like appendicitis, diverticular disease, cancer, and heart attacks." The makers of the product Branslim claim that the gram or so of bran it provides before each meal results in a feeling of satiety and so to a reduction in food intake. 
 

Now compare these claims with some conclusions in the report itself (my italics): "There is much evidence of an environmental factor at work in causing appendicitis, and possibly this is a lack of dietary fibre." "Patients with diverticular disease have probably eaten less dietary fiber than their diverticula-free compatriots." "There are reasonable grounds for the statement that, in genetically susceptible persons, large bowel cancer could be favorued by a fibre-depleted diet, but other explanations for the commonness of this cancer in Westernised countries are possible." "It is not yet possible to give specific recommendations to the general public about fibre's value in preventing heart attacks." "Although societies which exist on a fibre-rich diet have a low prevalence of obesity, this is not evidence that dietary fiber as such prevents obesity."

Neverless, it is a pity that the excellence of the report is marred by the  continual use of the inaccurate and misleading term "refined carbohydrate" in referring both to sugar and to white bread made from highly milled flour. It is inaccurate because white bread does not consist of pure starch but contains some 12% (dry weight) of protein, as well as significant amounts of vitamins and mineral elements. More important, the term "refined carbohydrate" is misleading because it implies that both sugar (sucrose) and white bread (or indeed starch) have the same effects on the body. But they have very different effects, and these differences are likely to be much more relevant to human disease than are the differences produced by wholemeal bread and white bread.
 

The major characteristic of Western diets is that, during the last 200-300 years, their total carbohydrate content has not changed much, but the nature of that carbohydrate has changed: the starch content has fallen considerably while the sugar content has risen to about the same extent. The association of "diseases of affluence" with changes in diet is at least as strong for this replacement of starch by sugar as they are for the diminution of dietary fibre.

​

Dietary sucrose increases the concentration in the blood of cholesterol  and triglyceride, and of uric acid and insulin, it also reduces the concentration of high density lipoprotein cholesterol. It leads to a diminution of glucose tolerance. Aggregation and adhesiveness of the blood platelets are increases, as is their electrophoretic mobility in the presence of ADP.

​

Dietary sucrose also results in several of the abnormalities seen in diabetics. In additon to diminished glucose tolerance and hypelipidaemia, it produces tissue insensitivity to insulin, retinopathy, and nephropathy. The most recent experiments show that the nephropathy is associated with changes in the glomerular basement membrane that are indistinguishable, in histology and in biochemistry, from the changes produced in experimental diabetes. It is tempting to see the production of the characteristics of both coronary heart disease and diabetes by dietary sugar as a clue to explaining the close clinical connection between the two diseases.

​

It should be stressed that most of these changes occur in experiments with amounts of dietary sugar that are well within the range of the amounts habitually consumed by individuals in Western countries. All of this information is hidden when we use "refined carbohydrate" indiscriminately to mean sugar, or products of highly milled cereals, or both.

John Yudkin

​

Jan 1, 1981

​

Open Entry:

​

​

1/1/81

Cancer was more common in those with low cholesterol.

URL

Event Rich Text

Jan 1, 1981

​

Open Entry:

​

Eating In America

1/1/81

“incorrect to describe Americans as great eaters of either [fruits or vegetables]”

It seems obvious, when one stops to think, that before large supermarket chains started importing kiwis from Australia and avocados from Israel, a regular supply of fruits and vegetables could hardly have been possible in America outside the growing season. In New England, that season runs from June through October or maybe, in a lucky year, November. Before refrigerated trucks and ships allowed the transport of fresh produce all over the world, most people could therefore eat fresh fruit and vegetables for less than half the year; farther north, winter lasted even longer. Even in the warmer months, fruit and salad were avoided, for fear of cholera. (Only with the Civil War did the canning industry flourish, and then only for a handful of vegetables, the most common of which were sweet corn, tomatoes, and peas.)

Thus it would be “incorrect to describe Americans as great eaters of either [fruits or vegetables],” wrote the historians Waverly Root and Richard de Rochemont. Although a vegetarian movement did establish itself in the United States by 1870, the general mistrust of these fresh foods, which spoiled so easily and could carry disease, did not dissipate until after World War I, with the advent of the home refrigerator.

So by these accounts, for the first two hundred and fifty years of American history, the entire nation would have earned a failing grade according to our modern mainstream nutritional advice.

Jan 1, 1982

​

Open Entry:

​

Retinopathy in adolescents and young adults with onset of insulin-dependent diabetes in childhood

1/1/82

Type 1 Diabetes researchers discover that low carb diets prevent retinopathy

Retinal studies were done in 181 postpubescent, insulin-dependent diabetic patients who developed diabetes before the age of 20. Retinal studies included serial direct ophthalmoscopic examinations, stereoscopic fundus photography and fluorescein angiography. At the time of retinal studies, muscle biopsies also were done to measure capillary basement membrane thickness (CBMT) as an index of early microvascular changes in skeletal muscles. Assessment of clinical metabolic control, interpretation of retinal findings, and CBMT were done independently. No retinopathy was detected in patients observed continuously and known to have been in higher degrees of metabolic control. Twenty-five patients in lower degrees of control for extended periods had retinopathy. CBMT was found to be labile and to progress or regress within a year depending on the degree of control. All patients in lower degrees of control with retinopathy had increased CBMT, but if they subsequently attained and maintained a high degree of control for a year, then CBMT diminished and there was no progression of retinopathy. Our study demonstrates that a high degree of metabolic control delays, and may prevent, microvascular changes, and confirms other studies indicating that most postpubescent, insulin-dependent diabetic patients will develop retinopathy within 15 years unless a relatively high degree of control is maintained.

Jan 1, 1982

​

Open Entry:

​

​

1/1/82

The 80's saw <30% cals from total fat and <10% for SFA and PUFA

Dietary Fat Recommendations

1982, 1986, 1988:

• <30% of calories from total fat (1982: 30-35%).

• <10% of calories from SFA.

• ≤10% of calories from PUFA.

Jan 1, 1982

​

Open Entry:

​

​

1/1/82

MRFIT results published.

URL

Event Rich Text

Gary Taubes wrote in his new book The Case For Keto a paragraph that I want to dedicate this database towards:

​

"I did this obsessive research because I wanted to know what was reliable knowledge about the nature of a healthy diet. Borrowing from the philosopher of science Robert Merton, I wanted to know if what we thought we knew was really so. I applied a historical perspective to this controversy because I believe that understanding that context is essential for evaluating and understanding the competing arguments and beliefs. Doesn’t the concept of “knowing what you’re talking about” literally require, after all, that you know the history of what you believe, of your assumptions, and of the competing belief systems and so the evidence on which they’re based?

This is how the Nobel laureate chemist Hans Krebs phrased this thought in a biography he wrote of his mentor, also a Nobel laureate, Otto Warburg: “True, students sometimes comment that because of the enormous amount of current knowledge they have to absorb, they have no time to read about the history of their field. But a knowledge of the historical development of a subject is often essential for a full understanding of its present-day situation.” (Krebs and Schmid 1981.)

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Reddit's r/Ketoscience
bottom of page