top of page

All History

Total Entries: 1046

Select one of the above filters

Year Filter:
Backwards
Recently Added
Clear Year
Search

Jun 12, 1930

​

Open Entry:

​

Getting Everybody to help put across the idea that "most foods are more delicious with sugar"....

6/12/30

The Sugar Institute's pamphlet describes the ten billion dollar market for sugar in 1930, as well as their usual slogans and where they run their advertisements.

"A word on wheels" is an apt description of a slogan. Once started on its way, its rhythmic sound makes its impression on millions of minds.

On the opposite page are the official slogans of The Sugar Institute, also a pictorial example of how they can be used by manufacturers of sweets and associated products.

The manufacturer who cooperates by the use of such slogans on his letter-heads and envelopes, and on his cartons and packages will materially increase the influence of The Sugar Institute's campaign.

And like "bread cast on the water", such support will result in an increased demand for every product thus labeled.

It is interesting to note that the dining-car systems of many railroads in the country are cooperating with The Sugar Institute by printing articles about sugar on their menus. And, as was the case in 1929, a number of restaurants all over the country are featuring the slogans of the Institute on their menus.

The value of this publicity is limitless.

And remember that such widespread featuring of sugar and sweet-foods can be maintained at practically no expense.


A Practical Experiment in Co-Operation

The above illustration is designed to suggest how the Official slogans of The Sugar Institute may be used on various food packages to assist in promoting a more favorable acceptance of the use of sweets and of associated products.


SLOGANS AND LETTERING

"A bit of sweet makes the meal complete."

"Good food promotes good health."

"Most foods are more delicious and nourishing with sugar."

"Refresh yourself with a flavored drink."

"Flavor with sugar."


And here is where you, a member of a ten billion dollar business, are definitely helped by The Sugar Institute. 

First let's look at the figures.


The tables on this page show the annual sales volume, at wholesale prices, of the "sweeteners" and principal lines of food production where sugar is used either as a component in the product itself or is added in the kitchen or at the table.


The Sweeteners

Sugar--Cane and Beet ....$710,400,000

Corn Syrups and admixtures....33,600,000

Corn Sugar.....25,700,000

Maple Sugar and Syrup....20,000,000

Honey.....16,900,000

Cane Syrup....1,300,000

Molasses.....1,000,000

Total.....$807,900,000


The Principal Lines of Manufacture Directly Interested in the Consumption of Sugar (sugar a component)

Bakery Products....$1,068,000,000

Confectionary Products....$467,000,000

Ice Cream....332,000,000

Carbonated Beverages...182,000,000

Condiments......117,000,000

Canned Fruits....99,000,000

Cereal Beverages....51,000,000

Flavoring Syrups.....38,000,000

Chewing Gum....63,000,000

Jams and Jellies.....38,000,000

Condensed Mlik.....35,000,000

Malt......21,000,000

Bakers' and Confectioners' Supplies..7,000,000

Fruit Beverages....7,000,000

Shredded Coconut....8,000,000

Malted Milk and Products....7,000,000

Ice Cream Cones....5,500,000

Liquors(Vinous)....3,500,000

Total......$2,549,000,000


Associated Lines Indirectly Interested in Increasing the Consumption of Sugar

Flour.....$1,200,000,000

Milk and Butter....$1,300,000,000

Eggs....580,000,000

Fresh Fruits....560,000,000

Coffee.....310,000,000

Cereal Products...114,000,000

Evaporated Milk....130,000,000

Baking Powder, Yeast....75,000,000

Dried Fruits....65,000,000

Shortening(Bakers')....55,000,000

Flavoring Extracts....32,000,000

Tea....28,000,000

Cocoa.....14,000,000

Powdered Skimmed Milk.....16,000,000

Coffee Substitutes....7,000,000

Total....$4,486,000,000


Summary

The Sweeteners...... $807,900,000

The Component Products.....$2,549,000,000

The Associate Products.......$4,486,000

Total.....$7,842,900,000


Supply Houses and other directly dependent on above(estimate).....$2,157,100,000


GRAND TOTAL......$10,000,000,000 [10 billion dollars]

Jun 13, 1930

Sam Apple

Open Entry:

​

Good News...! Public interest aroused by the Sugar Institute's Advertising campaign is reflected in the news and editorial columns of the nation's newspapers and magazines.

6/13/30

It almost feels like the #HAES movement was launched in 1930 by The Sugar Institute when you read the following disturbing passages. "Children are led to believe certain essential foods, necessary to build up strong, healthy bodies, are harmful because rats, fed on pre-arranged diets containing the food in question[sugar], fail to thrive." "Treat candy and other forms of sweets as food" "Medical professionals sanction a reasonable place of carbohydrate in the normal diet"

The Value of Sugar

If a word to the wise is sufficient, we would judge the American Public "wise."

A short while ago news columns were printing the evils of obesity, proclaiming the steadily mounting number of diabetics that were being treated each year and decrying the use of sweets. With such thoroughness did the public seize upon and use this knowledge that now a great wave of warning is being issued upon the dangers of the opposite extreme. The idea of dieting and keeping the boyish figure has taken such unnatural hold upon us that undernourishment and the attendant evils, such as inability to withstand infection and lowered fatigue time, are beginning to be noted by those who are interested in human welfare.


It is an interesting commentary that the Sugar Institute has seen fit to establish a definite campaign to regain the favor that threatened to be lost in this over-zealous response.


In this effort the medical profession can do nothing better than to sanction a reasonable place of carbohydrate in the normal diet, and point out the value of easily digested sweets in....(cut off)



"Quick Energy" for Quick Children

Childhood has a new heroine. All the curly-haired girls and the straight-limbed boys of this generation have added Dr. S. Josephine Baker to the little Hall of Fame which includes Santa Clause, Fairy Godmothers and Cinderella. Dr. Baker's elevation came with her recent pronouncement that candy is good for children, and that they should have it regularly.


"Treat candy and other forms of sweets as food", Dr. Baker says in the Ladies Home Journal. "Remember that they have a place in any well-balanced diet just as all other varieties of food have. Pure candy is a safe and requistite food for children as well as for adults. It has one advantage over plain sugar in the diet in that it contains not only sugar, but also variable amounts of other needed food elements, depending upon the type of candy selected.  


"The craving that children have for sweets is an expression of a definite bodily need. Children expend energy with a prodigal hand. If we are to give them the strength to meet this expenditure, their bodies must have a large reserve supply of energy-producing elements, and an additional sufficient amount for immediately available use. The reserve supply is made possible by the inclusion of sufficient fats and starchy foods in their diet. The quick energy food is sugar."


Wholesome Caution


Dr. J.S. Hughes, of the Kansas State Agricultural College, has rendered a genuine service to education as well as to economic sociology.

Rat professionalism has needed some scientific authority to say plainly what Dr. Hughes has said so effectively in his article in Hygeia, the Health magazine published by the American Medical Association.

Professionalism has suffered almost irrevocable harm by allowing loose statements and unscientific experiments to be favored because they are attractive by their newness. Dr Hughes says:--

"Children are led to believe certain essential foods, necessary to build up strong, healthy bodies, are harmful because rats, fed on pre-arranged diets containing the food in question, fail to thrive."


"Unfortunately, the experiments that are being conducted in many schools are giving children erroneous ideas concerning the influence of ordinary foods on their health. The experiments are planned on the old idea that certain foods are harmful, rather thatn on the modern view that it is leaving certain foods out of the diet that is harmful. It is from experiments of this type that the erroneous idea has become prevalent that...

Nov 2, 1930

​

Open Entry:

​

The Producer - published Monthly in the interest of the live stock industry of the US by the American National Live Stock Association Publishing Company

11/2/30

The editors of a livestock industry paper mock the claims of a Dr Keller who complained about the exclusive-meat diet experiment done a year beforehand and call him a "dietary zealot."

THE INTREPID FOOD CRUSADER REFORMERS ARE A HARD-DYING LOT.  Among the most persistent of the species is the dietary zealot. The man who conceives it to be his sacred mission to improve the eating or drinking habits of his fellow-beings will not accept defeat. Beaten at one end of the line, he immediately returns to the assault at the other. 


A couple of years ago an experiment was conducted in New York City for the purpose of testing the effects of an all-meat diet on the human system under conditions as found in the temperate zone. The laboratory material was the explorers Stefansson and Andersen, who had lived in the Arctics for long periods on the food of the native Eskimos, which is practically nothing but meat, and thrived on it. After a year’s time, during which the twain were subjected to rigid scientific control, the most painstaking examination failed to reveal the faintest trace of injury, physical or mental. 


Naturally, this did not “set well” with our food faddists. A number of alibis were at once forthcoming: The two men were exceptional specimens, of extraordinary toughness, inured to hardships and all manner of dietary irregularities; the period of trial had not been nearly long enough; anyway, what apparently had proved harmless in their case would not do at all for the average individual; etc., etc. 


To this chorus of denunciation is now added a note that we have not heard before. In Glendale, near Los Angeles, is a sanitarium which publishes a little magazine called Glendale Sanitarium Health Exponent, “devoted to the interests of better and finer living,” as stated on the title-page. The “summer number” of this periodical contains an article from the pen of P. Martin Keller, M.D., entitled “Does an Exclusive Meat Diet Insure Health?” In this we read: 


Recently in Los Angeles there could be found on the various large bill-posting boards the following statement: “Meat is the only single food which will sustain life for an unlimited time.” This, I suppose, was placed on the boards by the meat interests as a result of recent experiments of Dr. Lieb’s. He took as subjects Stefansson and Andersen, who have had experiences in the Arctic region. 


But, says the author, the two gentlemen “did not live entirely on a meat diet—they lived chiefly on fat (!): One-half pound of tallow and a few ounces of meat was their daily ration.” Stefansson, who had been placed on “an exclusive meat diet,” was compelled to give it up after a while and mix it with fat, as the lean ‘meat created “digestive disturbances.” Consequently, argues the writer, the contention that “an exclusive meat diet” insures health was not proved. 


Furthermore, Dr. Keller goes on, examinations have shown that the “intestinal contents of animals that live almost exclusively upon raw meat” harbor “large quantities of putrefactive bacteria” which, injected into guinea-pigs, kill. Not only that, but “a purely meat diet increases the work upon the heart.” This has been demonstrated by experiments on—cats. After a meal of meat, there was a rise in the rate of feline heart-beats “above the fasting level.” 


Just what it is sought to prove by this sort of stuff is not clear. Is it the doctor’s thesis that man, in order to insure health and long life, must not forget to mix his fat with his lean? Or that lions and tigers could get rid of the obnoxious bacteria which inhabit their intestines by having their meat well cooked? Or that cats do not know what is good for them, and could reduce their pulse-rate to the “fasting level,” thus insuring their “better and finer living,” by turning vegetarians? 


Effusions such as these could be ignored, or laughed out of court, were it not for the fact that too many people, in matters of diet, are in the habit of listening to, and being influenced by, anything, no matter how absurd or easily refutable, put out by quasi-experts in the name of science—especially if these have an M.D. handle to their names. 


It should not need restatement that no sane person has ever recommended a diet for human beings consisting wholly of raw meat, lean meat, meat mixed with fat, or meat in any other shape or combination. To intimate that stockmen, or anybody else connected with the “meat interests,” hold an exclusive meat diet to be a guarantee of good health is too absurd for a moment’s consideration. To ordinary logic the food fanatic seems as impervious as he is devoid of a sense of fair play. Either he concocts his arguments out of thin air, or he attempts to twist a laboratory demonstration of an isolated phenomenon into a law of universal application. Having set up a dummy to shoot at, nothing is too grotesque to serve as pellets for his little popgun. 


What live-stock men do stress is that meat, in the cold and temperate zones, is a natural, wholesome, and necessary food for man; that for the average healthy, active, human being, meat in even liberal quantities is an indispensable part of the daily diet, if full efficiency is to be maintained; that, under normal conditions, an ideal menu is one in which dairy products, vegetables, and fruits, in the right proportions (which everybody must determine for himself accord- ing to his individual needs) are grouped around meat as the central item; that, as an appetizing, tissue- building, strength-imparting food, meat has no equal; that the meat-eating nations throughout the centuries have been the nations of achievement; that among men noted for their accomplishments in war and peace, in art and science, in literature and music, the great majority in all ages have been meat-eaters; that in sanatoria for those of depleted systems—for those, for example, suffering from tuberculosis, diabetes, anemia, and other insidious diseases—chief reliance is placed in meat, meat and gland extracts, and other foods of high protein content, as an aid in building up the patient’s strength; that physicians, with few exceptions, testify to the faith that is in them by being generous partakers of meat themselves. 


These are facts, easily verifiable. But if further proof is needed of the effect of a meat diet, as compared with one of nothing but fruit and vegetables, visit a convention of vegetarians, or go to one of their restaurants, and then attend a meeting of stockmen, or sit down with a bunch of cow-punchers around the chuck-wagon, and notice the difference! 


Dr. Keller ends his discourse by painting a blood-curdling picture of the procession of innocent animals marching to the shambles to satisfy man’s cannibal appetite for flesh. The answer to this is that the sacrifice of lower forms in the interest of higher has always been, and always will be, a concomitant of organic life. As long as the destruction is not wanton, purposeless, unnecessarily painful, or likely to exterminate beneficial species, it is justifiable. Would the doctor extend his protecting hand of fellowship to the fly that drags its filthy legs over his Shredded Wheat biscuit, to the cockroach that devours his cracker, or to the mosquito that sucks his bacterium-free vegetarian blood? In his opinion, would it be less reprehensible to turn our herds of cattle out to die of cold or starvation, or to permit them to propagate their kind without check, until their numbers multiplied to such an extent as to spell wreck and ruin for every grain-and truck-farmer in the land? In that case, where would our vegetarians be?

Dec 31, 1930

​

Open Entry:

​

Mortality in the Native Races of the Territory of Alaska, with Special Reference to Tuberculosis

12/31/30

Judicial Divisions in Alaska show more cancer for more civilization in a 5 year U.S. Treasury Public Health Report for 1926 - 1930.

 Obviously, from the testimony presented so far, the frontier doctors of Alaska and northern Canada would have expected that statistics, if and when published, would confirm their view that the most civilized parts of northern territories would show the highest cancer incidence.

The chance to test this theory against the facts of statistically adequate population, and for a large and culturally differentiated area, did not come until the U.S. Treasury's Public Health Reports for March 2, 1934, carried “Mortality in the Native Races of the Territory of Alaska, with Special Reference to Tuberculosis," by F. S. Fellows, Passed Assistant Surgeon, United States Public Health Service, and Director, Alaska Medical Service.

The discussion by Dr. Fellows does have “special reference to tuberculosis.” But “malignancy" receives a column in the statistical tables, from which we can readily derive the information we need. The time covered is the five years 1926-30; the population, by the 1930 census, was around 60,000, about evenly divided between natives and whites, thus about 30,000 of each. As to causes of death, Dr. Fellows compares natives with whites and each of the four judicial divisions of Alaska with the other three. For my analysis of his cancer results I shall arrange the divisions in descending order of Europeanization. With an eye on the map (p. 91) and bearing history in mind, we may characterize the judicial divisions as follows:

Most intensively and longest civilized is the First Judicial Division, the Panhandle that stretches southeasterly along British Columbia. Its first European contacts were probably with Spain through Mexico in the 1500's. After Bering's voyage in 1741 the capital of Russian America was established at Sitka, where it remained even for some decades after the over-all name was changed to Alaska through purchase by the United States in 1867. Both before and after 1776 Yankee influence was considerable, as was British. After the purchase the influence of San Francisco was at first dominant, until Seattle and Vancouver took over.

Since the forest Indians of the Panhandle have been civilized the longest and most intensively of native Alaskans, the First Judicial Division ought to show the heaviest cancer incidence, according to the views of the frontier doctors whom we have quoted. That is the theory. Let us turn to statistics and seek the facts.

Table 2 of the Fellows paper is entitled “Actual and relative mortality from important causes among the native Indians and Eskimos and among the white population of Alaska during the five years 1926-30.” In the first third of this table, under “Average annual death rate per 100,000,” we find in the column marked “Malignancy” that in the First Judicial Division the white deaths from cancer are 92, the native 70. In the middle third of the table, under “Percent of all deaths due to indicated cause,” we learn that the white percentage from cancer was 7.8, the native 2.8. In the lowest third of the table, under “Number of deaths,” we learn that the whites who died of cancer were 59, the natives 21.


Map showing judicial divisions of Alaska

Historically the Third Judicial Division of Alaska ranks second among the divisions in Europeanization. It consists of the Aleutian island chain and of the southwestern corner of the mainland. Russian influence in the islands dates as far back as in the Panhandle, but the mainland part of the division was never intensively Europeanized. By the Tanchou-Le Conte principle, the native cancer rate should be fairly high but not as high as that of the Panhandle. According to Fellows' Table 2, the cancer figure per 100,000 is 75 for whites and 22 for natives; in percentages the whites rate 6.0 and the natives 1.4; in actual cancer deaths the whites have 33 and the natives 8.

The Second Judicial Division, from its history, should be in native cancer deaths the next to the lowest of the judicial districts, by the frontier theory. According to the tables of Dr. Fellows the per hundred thousand rate is white 126 to native 14; in percentages it is white 10.8 to native 0.8; in actual deaths the white are 9 to the native 6.

The Fourth Judicial Division should be lowest of the four in native cancer deaths. Here the population consists mainly of Athapaskan forest Indians who, except in becoming Christian, have resisted Europeanization much more successfully than either Eskimos or Aleuts, and far more successfully than the natives of the Panhandle.

According to Dr. Fellows the per hundred thousand rate is white 98, native 3; in percentage it is white 8.4, native 0.1; in actual number of cancer deaths the Fourth Judicial has white 27 and native 1.

The medical missionary theorists, those who favor the Tanchou-Le Conte principle, will think that the percentage table (the middle division of Dr. Fellows' Table 2) confirms their belief in most satisfactory fashion. In percentages of all deaths during the five years 1926-30, the cancer rate drops from the highest to the lowest of the districts on the scale as 7.8 to 2.8; 6.0 to 1.4; 10.8 to 0.8; and 8.4 to 0.1.

Jan 1, 1931

​

Open Entry:

​

Studies of nutrition. -- The physique and health of two African tribes

1/1/31

The Masai have a relatively very high intake of protein, fat and calcium, while the Kikuyu have a high intake of carbohydrate and a low one of calcium.

by J. B. Orr and J. L. Gilks

 - IV.-SUMMARY OF RESULTS. Preliminary observations and a review of existing information suggested that disease is more prevalent amongst native races than is generally supposed, and indicated that the incidence of certain diseases might be correlated with diet. A survey of two tribes, the Masai and Akikuyu, showed that the diet of the former consisted to a large extent of milk, meat and raw blood, and that of the latter mainly of cereals, roots and fruits, the bulk of the diet being cereals. The outstanding points of difference in chemical composition of the two diets were that the Masai have a relatively very high intake of protein, fat and calcium, while the Kikuyu have a high intake of carbohydrate and a low one of calcium. Differences were found in the dietary customs between men and women in both tribes, the diets of the females approaching in each case to the mean between the diets of the males. Physical measurements showed that the full-grown Masai male is on an average, 5 inches taller and 23 lb. heavier than the full- grown male Kikuyu, and his muscular strength, as determined by the dynamometer, is 50 per cent. greater. Marked differences were found in the incidence of disease in the two tribes, bony deformities, dental caries and anaemia, pulmonary conditions and tropical ulcer being much more prevalent amongst the Akikuyu. On the other hand, intestinal stasis and rheumatoid arthritis were more common amongst the Masai. Analyses showed that routine Hospital and Prison diets are markedly deficient in calcium, the average daily intake being only about 0.3 gm. Ca, as compared with the assessed requirement of about 1 gm. Examination of the blood of Kikuyu and other natives on a similar dietary showed that the concentration of calcium was lower than the European standard, the average of 90 cases, prisoners and farm labourers (not pathological) being 9.4 mg. per 100 c.c. serum, as compared with 10-0 to 10.5 mg. in Europeans at home, and 11.4 mg. in 13 Europeans in Kenya. The range of variation in blood calcium was wide, from 7.3 mg. to 11.2 mg., the highest figure being below the mean for Europeans in Kenya. -


It would be an interesting study to correlate diet and stature in different countries, to ascertain whether any correlation exists between the quality of the diet and mean adult stature. There are differences in the incidence of disease in the two tribes, and one of the tribes, the Akikuyu, show abnormalities in the composition of the blood. The diet of this tribe is very rich in carbohydrate, relatively rich in phosphorus, but deficient in calcium. Experimental data have been brought forward to lend support to the suggestion that deficiencies in the diet, abnormal composition of the blood and reduced susceptibility to certain diseases which have been noted in this tribe, may be correlated. The possibility that diet may influence the susceptibility to certain infectious diseases raises one of the most important problems in nutritional research. With regard to the bearing of the results of the investigation on conditions in Kenya, we are probably justified in concluding that the diet commonly in use amongst the Akikuyu and other tribes of similar customs is badly balanced, being too rich in carbohydrate and deficient in calcium. It is probably deficient also in other substances required as constructive material for growth, and in certain of the vitamins. On the other hand, the Masai, with a diet at the opposite extreme, possibly have too little vegetable food rich in carbohydrate and cellulose. Improvement might be brought about by increasing the use of green vegetables by both tribes, and of milk by the Akikuyu. The problem is therefore one which concerns not only medical and public health, but also agricultural authorities. A general improvement of agriculture and animal husbandry amongst the Akikuyu will almost certainly be accompanied by an improvement in the health and working capacity of the natives themselves. This problem is not confined to Kenya. It appears to exist in many different areas in our tropical dependencies. It may be judged from the introductory statements in the early part of this report that the loss of health and efficiency attributable to deficient diet is, therefore, of considerable economic importance.

Jan 1, 1931

​

Open Entry:

​

The Land of Feast and Famine

1/1/31

"I did well on this entirely meat diet and never missed bread, potatoes, salt, or sugar. I was never ill during the long winters, and my teeth were perfect."

URL

Sixty-five years ago I sold my thriving lawyer's practice in Norway and made for the Canadian wilderness of the Northwest Territories. For four years (1926—30) I lived as a trapper in the isolated region north-east of Great Slave Lake. I had decided to realize a dream that had always been with me: a primitive life in northern, practically uncharted wilds, in a region where the lives of the natives still largely followed their ancient traditions. 


The wilderness north-east of Great Slave Lake proved to be what' I had been looking for. After a long voyage by canoe, my partner Hjalmar Dale and I lit upon an enormous stretch of land with forests and tundras, extending to the Arctic Ocean in the north. A few groups of Indians, of Chipewyan stock, had their hunting grounds here. They were known as the Caribou-Eaters, a name they had received because their lives were utterly dependent on the caribou. At that time there were still great numbers - probably several hundred thousands — of caribou in the Northwest Territories. But the migrations of the caribou herds are mysterious. The Indians have a saying: "They are like ghosts; they come from nowhere, fill up all the land, then disappear." When thousands of these animals poured over the land, the Indians and the few white trappers there were filled with joy; when the animals disappeared, hunger and famine followed in their wake — at times, people starved to death. 


These were years of many long dog-sled journeys through forests and over the Barrens — they took me to the upper Thelon River and to other uncharted regions. The trappers were convinced that there were more wolves, more white foxes, in the far-off distances on the blue horizon, that it was there that the greatest riches were to be found. 


We lived off the land. Practically all of the caribou was eaten: meat, fat, marrow, brain, liver, kidneys, blood - sometimes we ate the contents of the stomach as well. I did well on this entirely meat diet and never missed bread, potatoes, salt, or sugar. I was never ill during the long winters, and my teeth were perfect. 


For a year I lived with a group of Indians ("CaribouEaters") in the inland forests, and I was the only white man there. I often think of these people with whom I shared everything for so long, and who became my good friends. It felt strange to become part of the world of the Indians, where so much ancient tradition was still alive. I imagine that most of these Indian friends of mine are dead by now, but I shall always remember them. The year I lived with them was not quite an easy year — but even though there were few caribou, we managed quite well, thanks to the Indians' skills and their principle of the hunt: the catch was shared by all. But the fate of three men who spent the year north of us was tragic — they all starved to death. 


Forty years later a Canadian friend visited me at home in Norway. He showed me a Canadian map, and to my great surprise I saw that a small river south-east of the southern part of Artillery Lake had been named after me. I had lived alone with my dogs in these parts by the very edge of the Barrens for a year, hunting and trapping wolves. From my tent I only needed to walk up a hill to see the endless Barrens. This was a good year, with plenty of caribou. And I had music almost every evening — on the hills around the wolves used to howl, and they were soon joined by the howling of my dogs. Quite an orchestra ... 


Today, the foreboding which I describe on the last page of this book has come true: civilization has invaded the Northwest Territories. When I was there, air traffic was only just starting. During all the years I was there, I saw only two small planes — today there are planes everywhere, there are oil wells, there are mines, there is commercial fishing and much else connected with modern life. At Snowdrift, that beautiful place by Great Slave Lake where the Hudson's Bay Company had a small trading post and where we trappers raised our tents together with the Indians, enjoying the light summer after the hardships of a long and cold winter, there are many houses now and alcohol is a danger. The polar dogs are largely being replaced by noisy snowmobiles. I am glad to have been born at a time when silence reigned in the wilderness, when dog teams and canoes were the only means of transport.

Jan 24, 1931

​

Open Entry:

​

'SICK HEADACHE.' How to Keep Well by Dr. W.A. Evans

1/24/31

Dr Barborka uses ketogenic diet for migraine. "He tried this by putting fifty migraine people, mostly men, on a diet which caused acidosis and keeping them steadily on this diet for six months. In this series he found that 28 per cent were cured of their migraine."

SICK HEADACHE:

(Copyright: 1931: By the Chicago Tribune)


The Sick headache that goes by the name "migraine" is nothing more than a group of disorders having headache and a few other symptoms in common, but produced by a considerable variety of causes. Some get an attack when they eat too much starchy food. Others are disabled by eating chocolate. In many cases migraine seems to be a close kinsman of nettlerash and asthma, and to be caused by acute sensitiveness. In these people migraine is an allergy disease.


There are others in whom still other causes are the principal offenders. In addition, there are many causes which operate as contributing factors. Among these are: Constipation, monthly phenomena in women, worry, excitement, poor sleeping, poor ventilation, and fatigue.


Dr. Barborka tried to discover what proportion of cases of typical, well established migraine were due to alkalosis or something related to it. He tried this by putting fifty migraine people, mostly men, on a diet which caused acidosis and keeping them steadily on this diet for six months. In this series he found that 28 per cent were cured of their migraine. Another fifty per cent still had attacks of sick headache, but they were further apart and the headaches were less severe. Something like the other 22 per cent were not improved in any degree.


The diet he used was known as the ketogenic diet. It is about the same as is used in epilepsy.

It is very high in fats, oils, and greases and is correspondingly low in bread, potatoes, sugar,

cereal, and other carbohydrates. The individual is, or should be, kept constantly in a state of acidosis as shown by laboratory tests. In so far as he could he did not change the routine of life of the people under trial except as to the diet. Practically speaking, one hundred per cent success

in such efforts is an impossibility. Try as hard as you please, the people under

such a régime do not live just as they did before. They worry less, or more; their outlook on life is different for the time; they work less, or more; exercise less, or more.

Something is always different. On the other hand, it is not always easy to keep a person in a condition of uniform acidosis. Eating so much fat and so little bread becomes very monotonous.


 The experiment proves that a fair part of those who have migraine can escape headaches by eating a diet rich in fats. Other trials have proved that still others can escape their headaches by other diets.

All in all, there is considerable chance that a person with migraine can be cured if he will persevere. 

Sep 3, 1931

Sam Apple

Open Entry:

​

Find Sugar is Fuel for Cancer - Develops Fastest Where Blood Has High Sugar Content - ADVISE DIET LOW IN CARBOHYDRATES

9/3/31

"The general conclusion is that cancer patients, particularly those with a high level of blood sugar, should be put on a low carbohydrate diet which should contain little or no sugar."

BUFFALO, Sept. 3 (P), Sugar is "fuel' for cancer, and its regulation in diet essential for cancer treatment, the American Chemical society was told yesterday. The report came from the cancer research department of the University of Pennsylvania, from work done by Gladys E. Woodward and Edith G. Fry, under direction of Dr. Ellice McDonald. 


"In cancer," said Dr. McDonald, in explaining the technical report, "the essential difference between tumor tissue and normal tissue is the ability of cancer to digest the animal sugar (or glycogen) in a different and more expeditious way than normal. "The greater the amount of sugar there is in the blood of cancer patients, the shorter is the expectation of their lives. There is a greater growth of the cancer when there is a large amount of sugar in the blood. The tumor grows faster, and there are a greater number of dividing cells. Cancer patients with a low blood sugar respond well to treatment and have a better chance of survival, with slow growth of the tumor.


"The amount of the sugar in the blood of cancer patients should be periodically measured, particularly before and after any treatment, for if the blood sugar increases after any treatment of the tumor, this should be corrected before any further treatment is instituted, and any new treatment should be based on the results of the tests. 


"The general conclusion is that cancer patients, particularly those with a high level of blood sugar, should be put on a low carbohydrate diet which should contain little or no sugar."

Jan 1, 1932

​

Open Entry:

​

New health for everyman.

1/1/32

Arbuthnot thinks roughage should be added to the diet to reduce intestinal diseases.

 In 1932, a ‘New Health’ movement was promoted in which people were urged to include plenty of roughage in their diets and it was hoped then that the prompt passing of stools after each substantial meal would reduce the incidence of intestinal diseases.

​

In the 1930s Arbuthnot Lanel promoted a "New Health" movement in which he urged, inter alia, that plenty of roughage should be included in the diet. Efficient defaecation and the passage of stools promptly after every substantial meal carried the hope that the incidence of intestinal disease would thereby be reduced. Thirty years later Burkitt suggested that the freedom of Africans from intestinal cancer might be related to their subsistence on coarse cereal foods, which promoted the frequent excretion of copious, loose stools.

http://www.thelancet.com.secure.sci-hub.tw/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(86)91316-4/fulltext

Jan 1, 1932

​

Open Entry:

​

Why I am not a vegetarian

1/1/32

Jarvis explains the Christian hygienic philosophy of Sylvester Graham's Bible oriented Garden of Eden lifestyle but explains why the vegetarian diet doesn't result in longetivity or good sources of nutrients such as B12, even describing a vegetarian RD who asked about getting B12 from vegetables.

East of Eden

It is possible to provide all essential nutrients except vitamin B12 without using animal foods. On the other hand, it is possible to provide all essential nutrients with a diet composed only of meat. Personal dietary appropriateness including the value of a diet as a source of essential nutrients and its value as a preventative for oneself and one's significant others is the foremost dietary consideration of pragmatic vegetarians. In contrast, the overriding dietary consideration of ideologic vegetarians varies with the particular ideology. Typically, their motivation is a blend of physical, psychosocial, societal, and moral, often religious, concerns.

A continual problem for SDAs who espouse the "back to Eden" ideology is the absence of a non-animal food source of vitamin B12. A vegetarian Registered Dietitian who wrote a column for a church periodical asked me if I thought vegans could derive vitamin B12 from organic vegetables that were unwashed before ingestion. I opined that it would be better to eat animal foods than fecal residues. She agreed.

A perennial assumption among vegetarians is that vegetarianism increases longevity. In the last century, Grahamites devotees of the Christian "hygienic" philosophy of Sylvester Graham (1794-1851) taught that adherence to the Garden of Eden lifestyle would eventuate in humankind's reclamation of the potential for superlongevity, such as that attributed to Adam (930 years) or Methuselah (969 years). I discussed this matter 25 years ago with an SDA physician who was dean of the Loma Linda University (LLU) School of Health. Although he admitted that lifelong SDA vegetarians had not exhibited spectacular longevity, he professed that longevity of the antediluvian sort might become possible over several generations of vegetarianism. SDA periodicals publicize centenarians and often attribute their longevity to the SDA lifestyle. However, of 1200 people who reached the century mark between 1932 and 1952, only four were vegetarians. 10 I continue to ask: Where on Earth is there an exceptionally longevous population of vegetarians? Hindus have practiced vegetarianism for many generations but have not set longevity records. At best, the whole of scientific data from nutrition-related research supports vegetarianism only tentatively. The incidence of colorectal cancer among nonvegetarian Mormons is lower than that of SDAs. 11 A review of populations at low risk for cancer showed that World War I veterans who never smoked had the lowest risk of all. 12 As data accumulate, optimism that diet is a significant factor in cancer appears to be diminishing. An analysis of 13 case-control studies of colorectal cancer and dietary fiber showed that, for the studies with the best research methods, risk estimates for dietary fiber and colorectal cancer were closer to zero.13 A pooled analysis of studies of fat intake and the risk of breast cancer that included SDA data showed no association. 14

A meatless diet can facilitate weight control because it is a form of food restriction. But one need not eliminate meat to maintain a healthy weight, and there are many overweight vegetarians. Surely prudence and selectivity overshadow mere abstention from consuming animal products.

Gary Taubes wrote in his new book The Case For Keto a paragraph that I want to dedicate this database towards:

​

"I did this obsessive research because I wanted to know what was reliable knowledge about the nature of a healthy diet. Borrowing from the philosopher of science Robert Merton, I wanted to know if what we thought we knew was really so. I applied a historical perspective to this controversy because I believe that understanding that context is essential for evaluating and understanding the competing arguments and beliefs. Doesn’t the concept of “knowing what you’re talking about” literally require, after all, that you know the history of what you believe, of your assumptions, and of the competing belief systems and so the evidence on which they’re based?

This is how the Nobel laureate chemist Hans Krebs phrased this thought in a biography he wrote of his mentor, also a Nobel laureate, Otto Warburg: “True, students sometimes comment that because of the enormous amount of current knowledge they have to absorb, they have no time to read about the history of their field. But a knowledge of the historical development of a subject is often essential for a full understanding of its present-day situation.” (Krebs and Schmid 1981.)

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Reddit's r/Ketoscience
bottom of page